I really think so many people just don't get it when it comes to judging defenders. Includes Liverpool football club as a whole.
Luckily, most good top flight managers do. That includes Wenger but he doesn't really do anything with the information.
So many people share Redknapp's outlook, but just listen to what Carragher says. Stick Maldini in Holding's shoes there, and I bet he has a bad game also. SIck and tired of saying it again and again.